Showing posts with label play. Show all posts
Showing posts with label play. Show all posts

Friday, February 12, 2010

Nostalgia for Play

By Justine Roberts
Last weekend I participated in the NAREA conference.  It was a two-day event – the first part was a reception held at the DeCordova Museum, and the second was a full day workshop anchored by Lella Gandini, US liason for Reggio.  I was asked to be part of a panel titled “Nostalgia For the Future”.

Five amazing women from Wheelock College, Project Zero, Reggio and Lesley University were going to speak about how Reggio had helped shape their practice and then I, along with 4 other people, were going to respond.

Initially I was confused by the title of the session. How can you be nostalgic for something that hasn’t happened yet?  How do you hold the past and the potential both in your mind at the same time?  It is a kind of idea mash-up. Where it led me, ultimately, was to the transformative power of memory.  Memory can inform our actions in the present, and therefore shape what is to come.  Specifically, when talking about children and childhood those memories are about play: Play Memories. What kind of world would we imagine, and be working toward, if we remembered how serious our own childhood activity was and began to see the children around us through that lens? To step back, childhood is rapidly changing.  Among the people I talk to there is a sense that childhood used to be more:
  • more connected to nature
  • freer and less cautious
  • more physical
  • more dangerous (in a good way)
  • messier
  • more open to possibility
The implication is that today’s children are growing up in a culture that is less able to prepare them for their futures.  In the museum field we believe our organizations add critical value to their communities. One way they do this is to preserve key childhood experiences and make them available to all.  Museums are the antidote to this sense of loss. I like the idea that children’s museums can somehow offer experiences that are relevant across generations and cultures - somehow essential to childhood.  And I think we summarize this idea of a critical ingredient that must be nurtured in children’s lives as PLAY.  That’s a tricky word since many people think of play as disorganized and purposeless. It is easier to talk about play through examples than in the abstract.  But it might be even more powerful to talk about play through an act of memory.  Imagine if adults though about the nostalgia they have for their own childhoods as a gift they could give to the next generation?

I have done an exhibit on play memories, although it was small. That exhibit, part of Go Kids at the Chicago Children’s Museum, uses smell as a trigger to induce adults to share stories from their childhoods with their children.  Children don’t always understand that adults used to be small!  So this component builds connections in both directions: adults relate their childhoods to the children in their lives today, while children develop a new connection with the adults who share their lives. 


Children’s and science museums are increasingly embracing adults as an audience in and of itself – not just as chaperones, or as a captured audience we might as well provide content for - as a central element of the museum visit, and of the child’s learning experience both at the museum and at home.  We need to ask what adults in this setting need and want.  And possibly we will find that reminding adults what the magical, not quite rational world of childhood feels like is a powerful bridge to understanding, appreciation, and partnership with the children in their lives.

Monday, February 8, 2010

National Play Policy?

By Justine Roberts, Principal

KaBOOM! is a playground company with a mission (literally, they are a non-profit): to provide play experiences within walking distance for every child in the country. That is an ambitious goal, and has led them to take on some exciting advocacy projects such as their just released report titled Play Matters: Best Practices in Play.

Wales was the first country ever to adopt a Play Policy. Published in October 2002, the Welsh Play Policy is a public commitment to providing an environment that supports the right to play, and recognizes the value of children’s play. The Welsh government intended this document to serve as a public affirmation of their commitment to children, and an opportunity to create a framework allowing children to be explicitly part of policy discussions.

In 2006 Play England, a part of the National Children’s Bureau and Play Council, published Planning for Play to promote the idea that local authorities should, and could, take responsibility for providing areas for children to play. The authors of this report argue that children at play signals a healthy community and therefore play connects to broader societal goals and priorities. Their report outlines a process for implementing a play policy that will result in more play opportunities. For example, they recommend creating Play Partnerships that include community members, agencies, and organizations; to establish a process for ongoing evaluation and assessment both as a basis for measurable outcomes and as a reflective practice; and to design for operational sustainability. They also identify critical ingredients of successful playscapes such as designing for adventure and providing risk and challenge. Their goal is for children’s needs to be incorporated into planning, design and policy discussions at the local level.

In the USA we do not have a national play policy or statement of children’s right to play. We aren’t even a signatory to the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child.

But we do have an active citizenry and a non-profit structure that makes it possible for many local initiatives to thrive. This is where KaBOOM!’s report comes in. Play Matters rounds up successful local efforts, and summarizes why they work. In doing so, Play Matters paints a picture of an emerging movement that may be changing the public realm from the bottom up.

At the same time, Play Matters makes the case that city-by-city solutions are not a sustainable long-term plan if we hope to achieve the types of changes that are necessary. They conclude “there is a national opportunity and imperative for play advocates to connect play and spaces conducive to play as part of a solution to. . .broader public priorities, and to help inform policymaking at the federal level.”

All of this is non-trivial. There is a well-documented play deficit in this country, and it is worse in under-served communities than in well-resourced neighborhoods. And there is growing research on the negative consequences of our approach to play. What have been a series of decisions effectively made in isolation of one another have started to coalesce into a grim picture of childhood without enough physical or creative activity, opportunities to rely on ones-self, to take risks and to stretch one’s capabilities. As Jeff Levi, Executive Director of the Trust for America’s Health has written, “Today’s children could be the first in U.S. history to live shorter, less healthy lives than their parents.” We are beginning to recognize that play may offer at least a partial solution to the challenges youth face today. But there is more to be done.

Image: Bay Area Discovery Museum "Sea Cave" by Gyroscope Inc.

Thursday, February 26, 2009

Hooray for Play!

maria mortati Our very own Justine Roberts brought this to my attention: Monday's New York Times published an article about the positive impact play time has on kids and the study that supports it. Read it, it's good, short, and informative. Basically, a collaborative group of researchers took 11,000 children between ages 8 and 9, and gave some recess, and others none. They found that the kids who had recess had better classroom performance than the kids without. Straight from the study's mouth:
"CONCLUSIONS. These results indicated that, among 8- to 9-year-old children, having > 1 daily recess period of >15 minutes in length was associated with better teacher's rating of class behavior scores. This study suggests that schoolchildren in this age group should be provided with daily recess." Source: http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/123/2/431
This is supportive data for our informal learning institutions, and builds on something that we've been preaching and practicing here at Gyroscope. One of the people noted in the article, Dr. Stuart Brown,is the founder of the National Institute of Play. They are gathering research from a diverse band of play scientists and:
" ... initiating projects to expand the clinical scientific knowledge of human play and translating this emerging body of knowledge into programs and resources which deliver the transformative power of play to all segments of society." Source: http://www.nifplay.org/
Their board includes the likes of Jane Goodall, folks from IDEO, the Jonas Salk Foundation, and so on. No museum folks... Anyway, according to Ms. Parker Pope, Brown considers play:
“a fundamental biological process.” “From my viewpoint, it’s a major public health issue,” he said. “Teachers feel like they’re under huge pressures to get academic excellence to the exclusion of having much fun in the classroom. But playful learning leads to better academic success than the skills-and-drills approach.”
That fits nicely with my personal experience: I remember things best when I'm having fun. Thanks, Justine!